2012年1月3日 星期二

讀者來函

December 27, 2011 10:05 pm, Editorial, FT
Old warriors play the best politics: they have some experience of how the world actually works rather than just how they would like it to work.
Just over half a century ago, at the start of 1961, Harold Macmillan, then the prime minister of Britain, was about to celebrate his 67th birthday. Among the world’s great leaders he was a junior figure. He was two months older than Nikita Khrushchev and two months younger than Chairman Mao Zedong. Meanwhile, the presidents of the US and France, Dwight D. Eisenhower and Charles de Gaulle, were both 70; the Indian prime minister Jawaharlal Nehru was 71 and Chiang Kai-Shek of Taiwan, who held the Chinese seat at the UN, 73. All of them were mere whippersnappers compared to “Der Alte”, Chancellor Konrad Adenauer of West Germany, 85.
This global gerontocracy was, however, on the brink of revolution. Before January 1961 was out, John F. Kennedy, 43, was inaugurated as Eisenhower’s successor and proclaimed that the torch had been passed to a new generation. But it was not just a generational change, it was a huge cultural shift.
The perception was that Kennedy had been elected because he looked good on TV. And from that moment on, Kennedyesque qualities – youth, vigour, good looks, a plausible manner – would be the most prized virtues in electoral politics. If one counts Gore as the real winner in 2000, the last five presidential and six of the last eight UK elections have been won by the younger contender.
The leaders of Macmillan’s generation had almost all fought to save, free or revolutionise their countries and had seen their comrades die. Political power was the culmination of an eventful life. The three pre-eminent figures in the current British Cabinet are prime minister David Cameron and deputy prime minister Nick Clegg, both 44, and chancellor of the exchequer George Osborne, 39. Their combined experience of life outside politics is negligible. The only one ever to hold what might be termed a real job is Mr Cameron, a former public relations officer for a television company, which does somehow encapsulate the problem of modern politics.
Who are the two most vibrant, adventurous and interesting ministers in the government? There is a strong case for nominating the justice secretary, Ken Clarke, 70, and the business secretary, Vince Cable, 67. They are the two oldest members of the cabinet by miles; there is no one else over 60. Both have a tendency towards candour which has taken them to the edge of enforced resignation: Mr Cable when he attacked Rupert Murdoch before it was fashionable; Mr Clarke when he said that some types of rape were not as serious as others, a self-evident truth (the technical term for which, in politics, is ”gaffe”).
Both give the impression that leaving office would not be a catastrophe, but that they would like to achieve things before it happens. Both speak plain English to voters rather than regurgitating their briefs. Both convey a sense that they have some experience of how the world actually works rather than just how they would like it to work.
The phrase “speaking truth to power” has become fashionable in the media. There are very few who ever try to speak truth from power. Yet Mr Clarke has talked frankly about the defects of the prison system in a manner that was unthinkable amid the right-wing orthodoxies of penal policy during the Labour years. Mr Cable has offered a counterweight to Treasury orthodoxy that would be impossible in a conventional one-party government.
For most ministers, the main object of office is to continue in it. It is a recipe for policy decisions that are either timid or ego-driven. The US constitution has minimum age requirements: 25 for the House of Representatives, 30 for the Senate, 35 for the Presidency, rules laid down in an era when life expectancy was much lower. Britain might be better run if its government had similar but sterner restrictions.

沒有留言: